Reviews



Restaurants, Modern Australian

Overall 8  31

8.3 Highly Recommended

Food  9      Ambience  7      Service  9      Value  8     


Love it! Having just moved to Avalon from Bondi we're excited to find a range of excellent restaurants in the area. Starfish was a fantastic find. We had dinner on Friday night. The restaurant was fairly full and it had a nice atmosphere, but could do with some music.

I had a special of kingfish sashimi - it was very fresh, not tough as you would expect from raw kingfish. Then I had the pork belly. I can't seem to go past pork belly on a menu - and this time I had a good reason. The night before we went to Brass Razoo and I had pork belly - it had no crackling! Very disappointed, so I had the pork belly at Starfish to compare - and it won. Delicious crackling, very tender meat lovely sauce.

After all of this I didn't really have room for dessert, but my belly won and I ended up with sticky date pudding. Superb.

Sep 20, 2008

Was this review helpful?   |



Bars, Music Venues

Overall 8  20

7.8 Recommended

Drinks  7      Ambience  9      Service  8      Value  7     


Upstairs is my fav. The comfy couches and soft lighting sets the mood for gossip and chat. Love the food upstairs, hate the food downstairs.

Apr 10, 2008

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, French, Japanese, Modern Australian, Fine Dining

Overall 8.1  520

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful

9.3 Highly Recommended

Food  10      Ambience  9      Service  10      Value  8     


All I can say is you have to go there, and don't be tight with your money - expect to pay around $600 for 2. Then just sit back and enjoy yourself in a little time vacuum.

Jan 05, 2007

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, Italian, Child Friendly, Licensed, Outdoor Dining

Overall 5.9  117

4.8 Average

Food  4      Ambience  7      Service  5      Value  3     


I have to agree with most of the others here, the food is not that good. It's such a super spot, and full of promises, but there's not much effort in what came out of the kitchen. My steak was drowned in olive oil and my dining partners chicken dish was made with cheapo chicken pieces that had tiny unexpected bones in it (and yes, she did choke on them!). I won't be going back until they acknowledge their faults and improve.

Jan 05, 2007

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, Modern Australian, BYO, Has Bar, Licensed

Overall 7  86

7.3 Recommended

Food  6      Ambience  8      Service  9      Value  6     


Mmm, I had a really enjoyable night here, but we went just after they were crowned with two hats and the food just seems a long way from three hats. I've eaten at three hat restaurants, so I was very much looking forward to eating at a local two hat. The food was good, actually really tasty with fresh ingredients, but it was not inspiring and didn't quite make me go wow. It's very honest food and the service and atmosphere do make it a very enjoyable occasion, but nothing that a really good home cook couldn't do.

Jan 05, 2007

Was this review helpful?   |



More Reviews...

Photos




Profile

Member since 2006

Last updated on 1st Jun 2012





Reviews

Sort by Review Rating Review Date


 

Displaying: 1 - 7 of 7 reviews




Restaurants, Modern Australian

Overall 8  31

8.3 Highly Recommended

Food  9      Ambience  7      Service  9      Value  8     


Love it! Having just moved to Avalon from Bondi we're excited to find a range of excellent restaurants in the area. Starfish was a fantastic find. We had dinner on Friday night. The restaurant was fairly full and it had a nice atmosphere, but could do with some music.

I had a special of kingfish sashimi - it was very fresh, not tough as you would expect from raw kingfish. Then I had the pork belly. I can't seem to go past pork belly on a menu - and this time I had a good reason. The night before we went to Brass Razoo and I had pork belly - it had no crackling! Very disappointed, so I had the pork belly at Starfish to compare - and it won. Delicious crackling, very tender meat lovely sauce.

After all of this I didn't really have room for dessert, but my belly won and I ended up with sticky date pudding. Superb.

Sep 20, 2008

Was this review helpful?   |



Bars, Music Venues

Overall 8  20

7.8 Recommended

Drinks  7      Ambience  9      Service  8      Value  7     


Upstairs is my fav. The comfy couches and soft lighting sets the mood for gossip and chat. Love the food upstairs, hate the food downstairs.

Apr 10, 2008

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, French, Japanese, Modern Australian, Fine Dining

Overall 8.1  520

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful

9.3 Highly Recommended

Food  10      Ambience  9      Service  10      Value  8     


All I can say is you have to go there, and don't be tight with your money - expect to pay around $600 for 2. Then just sit back and enjoy yourself in a little time vacuum.

Jan 05, 2007

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, Italian, Child Friendly, Licensed, Outdoor Dining

Overall 5.9  117

4.8 Average

Food  4      Ambience  7      Service  5      Value  3     


I have to agree with most of the others here, the food is not that good. It's such a super spot, and full of promises, but there's not much effort in what came out of the kitchen. My steak was drowned in olive oil and my dining partners chicken dish was made with cheapo chicken pieces that had tiny unexpected bones in it (and yes, she did choke on them!). I won't be going back until they acknowledge their faults and improve.

Jan 05, 2007

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, Modern Australian, BYO, Has Bar, Licensed

Overall 7  86

7.3 Recommended

Food  6      Ambience  8      Service  9      Value  6     


Mmm, I had a really enjoyable night here, but we went just after they were crowned with two hats and the food just seems a long way from three hats. I've eaten at three hat restaurants, so I was very much looking forward to eating at a local two hat. The food was good, actually really tasty with fresh ingredients, but it was not inspiring and didn't quite make me go wow. It's very honest food and the service and atmosphere do make it a very enjoyable occasion, but nothing that a really good home cook couldn't do.

Jan 05, 2007

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, Steak House, Has Bar, Licensed, Serves Dinner

Overall 6.8  246

7 Recommended

Food  8      Ambience  6      Service  7      Value  7     


Don't get the ribs takeaway - just not the same. If you want the best ribs in Sydney you have to eat in the restaurant. And they are the best ribs in Sydney, don't bother trying anything else, oh, except for the garlic prawns.

Nov 28, 2006

Was this review helpful?   |



Restaurants, Modern Australian, Good for Brunch, Good for Business Dining, Good For Groups

Overall 5.6  61

7 Recommended

Food  8      Ambience  7      Service  7      Value  6     


I'm really surprised by some of these comments. I went here for a tapas dinner and it was fantastic. Some of the dishes were amazing and very unique, unlike any taste sensations I've had before. Service was a bit slow but really you don't want to be rushed on a Sat night do you?

Nov 28, 2006

Was this review helpful?   |




 

Displaying: 1 - 7 of 7 reviews



Scroll map



No photos yet






Book a Restaurant Table
Daily Deals
Special Offers
Best of Sydney

Order Takeaway
Free to order | No markup
Book a Hotel Room
Where?
No fees | Best rate guaranteed

Arrive

Depart



Anonymous photo Anonymous

Login / Register

Recently Viewed
Tell a Friend

Lists

    No items


New List

Add

Body Left Cached User Nav : showCached : true, time: 0ms


Newsletter

Get deals, specials & news!

Sign Up
View a previous newsletter


Browse Sydney

expand Arts & Leisure
expand Health & Beauty
expand Hotels
expand Restaurants & Nightlife
expand Services
expand Shops

Restaurants & Nightlife Categories

expand Cuisines
expand Dining Atmospheres
expand Dining Features
expand Hotel Amenities
expand Bookings Online
expand View
expand Dietary Standards
expand Parking Facilities
expand Delivery, Pick Up & Catering
expand Awards
expand Internet Access
expand Accessibility
expand Arts & Crafts
expand Fitness & Recreation
expand Guided Tours
expand Hotel Room Facilities
expand Parking Types
expand Pool, Spa & Gym Facilities
expand Public Amenities
expand Sport Types

Within Sydney




Close