eatability sydney local restaurant reviews - restaurant guide  

 

 

 

 

the people's voice for gastronomic choice!

 

HomeGuidesTop 10Book Real-timeBook via Booking Angelspecial offer Special OffersRegisterTell a FriendAdvertiseRestaurateursLogin

 Featured Offer

Mizuya

Lunch Set Specials - from $13!

 Featured Offer

Mantra Indian Restaurant

Three amazing offers

 Featured Offer

Sorenzo

Three Mid Week Offers

 Featured Offer

Capital Grill & Bar

5 course degustation $59

 Featured Offer

Summer House

2 crs $28, 3 crs $35 incl. wine

 Featured Offer

Mediterranean

Exciting Greek Ent - Book your Xmas party now!

 

good food user Hi, Anonymous

Login / Register
Login / Register

your lists

    No Items.

add new list

add Pizza Mario @ St. Margarets to your new list
 

 

search

e.g. name or postcode or suburb
advanced search

 

 

locality guide

Find

in the region of

 

 

 

order food new!

 

 

atmosphere

   
 

 

cuisine

   
 
 
 

 
 

cuisine features

   
 

 

special features

 
 

 

Sydney newsletter

 

 
 
   

 



Pizza Mario @ St. Margarets

Overall Rating

7.2

 bullet Read 90 reviews 
 bullet Review this restaurant 

 

 

St. Margaret's Shop 9, Ivy
417 - 421 Bourke St
Surry Hills NSW 2010


Phone (02) 9332 3633

 

 

Look for

bullet Italian Restaurants in Sydney

bullet Pizza Restaurants in Sydney

 

What's nearby Pizza Mario @ St. Margarets

bullet Restaurants & Cafes around Surry Hills

bullet Bars & Pubs around Surry Hills

 
 
 Manage this Listing free! 

 

Pizza Mario @ St. Margarets Details

St. Margaret's Shop 9, Ivy
417 - 421 Bourke St
Surry Hills NSW 2010
Phone (02) 9332 3633

view map Map

Cuisine

Italian, Pizza

Notes

Trading from 6 - 10pm, 7 nights a week. No BYO or bookings.

 





Overall Rating              7.2  
 
Food                8.0  
Ambience                7.0  
Service                6.6  
Value                6.7  

 

Recommended based on 90 votes
(The Overall Rating is calculated using a Weighted Average)
       
 

 

 Been here? Rate Pizza Mario @ St. Margarets, Surry Hills!
 

 

Please read our review guidelines and tips

 

 Awful Mediocre Perfect
  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10  
Food  
Ambience  
Service  
Value  
 
 Your Review *  
 
 

 

Already a member? Please login:

 

 Login Name  
 Password  
 Keep me logged in on this computer unless I logout   help
 (Non members may register on the next page)

 

 

 



Related Editorial Content


 

User Reviews on Pizza Mario @ St. Margarets


 
Displaying 1 - 10 of 90 comments
 
Page: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9   Next
 

 

 

Overall             Average
Food 4 Ambience 6 Service 5 Value 5

 

I have no idea how this place got accreditation from the Associazione Vera Pizza Napoletana, cause this didn't hit the mark. The pizza bases were not quite cooked through, which was sorely disappointing. And I was dumbfounded that the mushrooms on the mushroom pizza were Shiitake. Asian mushrooms on a napoli pizza?! It was weird and not good.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
Jamie05  -   See my reviews 1review, 07 July 2010
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Not Recommended
Food 1 Ambience 4 Service 1 Value 3

 

What happened to this place? I used to enjoy eating at Pizza Mario. I went back last night to satisfy a pizza craving and was bitterly disappointed. The service has been on a downward spiral for a while and it seems to have hit rock bottom. Rude and arrogant to say the least.

$45 for one pizza, bottle of water and a side salad, there doesn't seem to be much value in that. The food was horrific, there were a 'generous' 2 slices of tomato and 3 pieces of bocconcini. The pizza was very soggy and needed to be eaten with a spoon.

I'm not sure what is going on with the hygiene either, both of us who ate there fell ill since our meal last night. We will never eat at or recommend Pizza Mario again.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
food250  -   See my reviews 1review, 27 June 2010
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 8 Ambience 8 Service 8 Value 7

 

Pizzas are generally really goo, the Calabrese, Margerita and Capriosca deserve mention but the Spicy sausage with Cime de Rape (which turned out to be Broccoli) was pretty boring and tasteless. The dough itself was fantastic but, perhaps, a little soggy in the middle? but so light and fluffy but thin all the same.

The service was pretty good, no complaints but I can see how people would find them a bit stuck up. I did find the prices for the pizzas a bit expensive for the size of them. I would like to go back and try the proscuitto pizzas and to have the Calabrese again.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
hungryhippoo  -   See my reviews 21reviews, 01 May 2010
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 9 Ambience 8 Service 8 Value 7

 

Pizza's are amongst best I've had in Sydney. The bases are perfect, everything else is great, sauces, toppings, cheese. Great atmosphere, nicely located (hidden away) in Surry Hills. Pizza's are a little small and a little on the pricey side, but well worth it.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
anthonyxf  -   See my reviews 22reviews, 29 January 2010
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 8 Ambience 8 Service 8 Value 7

 

Solid, reliable food & service. They always deliver a fantastic pizzas (minus the one with broccoli!), friendly welcome and fast service. Now, just if they were open for weekend lunch!
 
Was this review helpful?
 
Oztsunami  -   See my reviews 7reviews, 23 December 2009
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Highly Recommended
Food 9 Ambience 9 Service 9 Value 8

 

We though the experience was very good overall. Very courteous waiters, and the food was great. We did hear a table next to us complaining about how rude the waiters were, but they need to get over themselves. They were doing the best they could, and having the customers be so rude wouldn't exactly help the situation. I have had better pizza's, but it would be up there in the top 3 in Sydney. Very nice.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
LoganTT  -   See my reviews 3reviews, 12 November 2009
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Below Average
Food 5 Ambience 3 Service 1 Value 1

 

Quite a few friends had been recommending this place and with us doing grocery shopping in the nearby Woolies, we decided it was finally time to check it out. On arrival, we were greeted in a very rude manner (more like not greeted at all) and it took us a minute or two, neglect by the wait staff meant we could just choose any table available.

In general, one of the waiters was an absolutely unfriendly, almost rude person, the other one at least could afford to smile but found talking to some personal friends on nearby table more worthwhile than caring about all the other guests. The food is nice but way overrated, especially as they prices are way too high. There are better Italians with less of a pricetag around, particularly in Surry Hills.

Also, the restaurants boasts being an authentic Italian place and even shows off some Italian memberships on the menu while all their kitchen staff obviously stems from the Asian continent.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
Berlinsydney  -   See my reviews 34reviews, 11 November 2009
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Average
Food 8 Ambience 7 Service 1 Value 3

 

I have never been greeted so rudely in a restaurant before. If I wasn't with friends who wanted to eat there, I would have turned around and walked out! Just rude! Sorry I put you out by coming to your restaurant. Great pizza, but you will pay for it. I'm never going back.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
Eno  -   See my reviews 6reviews, 20 October 2009
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 8 Ambience 8 Service 9 Value 8

 

We went back on Sunday night, feeling a bit nervous after some of the recent reviews, but we were not disappointed! We loved the delicious pizza and school prawns and the service was fast, efficient and friendly as always. Can't top that insalata mista, what olive oil do they use its the best? We finished off with an affogato which went down a treat. Still our favourite pizza spot overall.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
vietnamesenoodles  -   See my reviews 1review, 21 September 2009
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Average
Food 5 Ambience 6 Service 7 Value 2

 

What happened to this place? My recent experiences there yielded nothing but disappointment. 2 of my recent 3 forays there had been bad. The pizza (in particular the potato topping), was undercooked and for that price, certainly inexcusable. This used to be my favourite pizza haunt, but I am now embarassed to have recommended this venue to friends. Can we please have some quality control, as I know that they can do much better than current form.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
hapydiner  -   See my reviews 9reviews, 15 August 2009
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 


Displaying 1 - 10 of 90 comments
Page: 1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9   Next


 
 

Featured Offers


special offer   Alio
East Redfern
 
special offer   bel mondo
The Rocks
 
special offer   Bistro Lilly
Sydney
 
special offer   Blancharu
Elizabeth Bay
 
special offer   Borruso's Pizza & Pasta
Northbridge
 
special offer   Cala Luna
Mosman
 
special offer   Capital Grill & Bar
Circular Quay
 
special offer   Chedi Thai
Newtown
 
special offer   Dedes Bar & Grill
Abbotsford
 
special offer   La Tratt
Fairfield
 
special offer   Mantra Indian Restaurant
Ryde
 
special offer   Mediterranean
Surry Hills
 
special offer   Mino Japanese
Mosman
 
special offer   Mizuya
Sydney
 
special offer   Sanders Waterfront
Cabarita
 
special offer   Sorenzo
Meadowbank
 
special offer   Spice Me Up
St Leonards
 
special offer   Summer House
Fairfield
 
special offer   Tandoori Palace
Darlinghurst
 
special offer   Umi Kaiten Zushi
Haymarket
 
special offer   Waqu
Crows Nest
 
special offer   Zaaffran
Darling Harbour
 

See All Special Offers

       
   

Home | Guides | Top 10 | Book via Booking Angel | Special Offers | Contact Us | About Us | Register | Advertise | Restaurateurs | Login



© Eatability Pty Ltd 2003-10. All Rights Reserved. Terms and Conditions ..