Love Supreme

6.8 Recommended

Food  8      Ambience  9      Service  5      Value  5     

Ok, the service is poor and it gets busy and hot; so you need to be prepared for that. If you are prepared for that the variety of pizzas are great and they are delicious. Some of the prices amaze me, especially a bottle of water and olives. The rest of it ain't bad. The veggie tasting place used to be a big hit with my wife, she is disappiointed the frittata has gone... please come back!

Mar 16, 2008 

7.8 Recommended

Food  9      Ambience  8      Service  7      Value  7     

Friendly smiles, little slow, but relaxed service, quite a few different waiters/waitresses offering water top-ups and what not, great thrown-together atmosphere with the boxes stacked high everywhere giving the impression they are always busy, AND most importantly, some extremely tasty pizza with clever yet authentic topping combinations.

Too often pizzerias here in OZ try for the creative combos such as tandoori or kebab pizza, but I love it when a place such as Love Supreme can pull off a prosciutto, shaved parm' and roasted tomato pizza with class, perfectly cooked crust to boot.

Coming from the land proclaimed by most (including proudly myself) as having arguably THE best pizza, New York, I can honestly say that Love Supreme is some of the most sincere thin crust pizza I've found thus far in Sydney (and I've searched).

I am not quite sure what establishment some of the rest of these reviewers have visited, but every time we have either dined at Love Supreme or ordered home delivery it has been surprisingly fantastic. Give it a go for yourself...

Mar 14, 2008 

3.5 Below Average

Food  8      Ambience  4      Service  1      Value  1     

After waiting for 45 minutes for 2 pizzas we discovered our order never made it to the kitchen. So 15 minutes later the pizzas arrived and just to make the evening worse one of the two pizzas we order was not what we have ordered. Then we pay about $70 for 2 pizzas and 2 bottles of water. Not going back there anytime soon.

Mar 07, 2008 

6.3 Average

Food  9      Ambience  7      Service  1      Value  8     

Food, fabulous, can highly recommend it. Service, terrible. Had the most horrible waitress who when I asked for some water, threw the glass on the table and was completely miserable. I am a very nice customer, not demanding but the waitress was terrible.

I'd go back but it is never a nice experience when the waitress is a rude cow!

Feb 14, 2008 

6.5 Recommended

Food  8      Ambience  7      Service  4      Value  7     

For what it is the food is great, its not the best value for money but it's not the sort of restaurant you would want to visit weekly. The food came out fast but the waiters were not. We sat near the kitchen up the front, there is alot of clutter laying around and clashes with the rest of the restaurant, which I think is quite nice. I don't know if the air conditioner was broken but it was unpleasantly hot. I like the pizza but will probably stick to home delivery.

Jan 16, 2008 

6.8 Recommended

Food  8      Ambience  8      Service  6      Value  5     

Had a dinner for two after a friend's recommendation. The place was quite crowded despite it being mid-week. We were quite relaxed as the atmosphere provided a cozy and sociable buzz. We did have to exert some effort to get the attention of the waiter(s) but this was forgivable at the time since we were in a happy, laid-back mood.

We ordered a pizza each. The sizes of the pizzas aren't generous, I would recommend ordering 'one size up' to what you would expect at your average pizzeria. Don't get me wrong, this place is not 'expensive' as such, but I fear other people's ratings for 'value' have been morphed due to a pleasant overall experience.

We felt the same way. Quite a unique twist on the menu, they have a "Surprise" pizza which contains "???". We ended up ordering one surprise and another pizza of our choice as a 'backup' in case the surprise was a disappointment. We weren't disappointed however. The surprise turned out to be a delicious orchestration of feta cheese, spinach and other fresh ingredients. The table next to us also ordered a surprise and got a completely different result.

The pizza itself is on the thinner side, which draws focus to the delicious toppings. It was baked to perfection. I would happily go again with friends or a partner if I was after a light-hearted and enjoyable pizza experience.

Jan 04, 2008 

8.3 Highly Recommended

Food  8      Ambience  8      Service  9      Value  8     

Maybe someone has been reading these reviews because our waiters were noticeably attentive. One of our group has hearing loss and they turned the music down on request. We were a group of 8 and just had pizzas and salad and our BYO wine. The pizza was really good and having just come back from Italy I have high standards. Great place for table of friends, buzzy but not too loud. Probably wouldn't go for dinner for two.

Dec 03, 2007 

5.8 Average

Food  8      Ambience  8      Service  1      Value  6     

Yes, service is a major issue for this place and best avoided on a busy Sat night. We were asked to put our names on a list and come back in 40 minutes, which we did happily. Upon our return there was no sign of the list and we were asked to come back in another half hour. When we were finally seated two different waiters told us they'd be right back to take our orders to never be seen again (one to chase up a wrong order for the table next to us).

We finally got someone's attention and were told they would have to get someone else. Nothing is written down and the wait staff rely solely on memory, which is why so many people seemed to have incorrect orders. That would explain the 'surprise' pizza on the menu! Ultimately the food was great, but not sure it was worth the fuss. Go expecting the worst service in Sydney, it may exceed your expectations.

Nov 09, 2007 

5.8 Average

Food  4      Ambience  8      Service  6      Value  5     

Being a Paddo local, was delighted when this place opened up. Have been a few times and despite the slow service, have found the pizzas tasty, and the vibe in the place is great. However, brushettas are so tiny it's a joke.

Also, last time we went they got our orders wrong, and then my friends pizzas were nothing better than ordinary and mine (Ava) was sloppy, oily and frozen spinach was used. Not impressed. They are popular and always full but they need to lift their game and ensure that the standards don't slip.

Oct 19, 2007 

7.8 Recommended

Food  9      Ambience  7      Service  8      Value  7     

I went to Love Supreme with some trepidation after reading the reviews, but I have to say that my partner and I were really happy with the excellent service we received! the waiter was attentive, helped us choose great food and when there was a small bill error it was cleared up quickly and staff were sincerely apologetic.

We both agree that the portion sizes could be larger, especially of the pasta dish made out of giant pasta shells (delicious!!!!). Overall a great dining experience, we will eat there again and thank you!

Oct 18, 2007