eatability sydney food guide  

 

 

 

 

the people's voice for gastronomic choice!

 

HomeGuidesTop 10Bookingsspecial offer Special OffersRegisterTell a FriendAdvertiseRestaurateursLogin

 

 Featured Offer

Sanders Waterfront

2 crse $37 / 3 crse $47, BYO

 Featured Offer

Sea la vie

Dee Why Beach Free Dessert Conditions Apply

 Featured Offer

Limani

Free bottle of wine when you dine with us

 Featured Offer

Elevate

Buy a main, get a free dessert or cocktail

 Featured Offer

Sam Satay

Malaysian Traditional Banquet for $33

 Featured Offer

Adriatic

Introductory discount - 20% off our mains!

 

 

good food user Hi, Anonymous

Login / Register
Login / Register

your lists

    No Items.

add new list

add Balmain Stars at GiGis' to your new list
 

 

search

e.g. name or postcode or suburb
advanced search

 

 

locality guide

Find

in the region of

 

 

 

atmosphere

   
 

 

cuisine

   
 
 
 

 
 

cuisine features

   
 

 

special features

 
 

 

Sydney newsletter

 

 
 
   

 



Balmain Stars at GiGis'

Overall Rating

6.9

 bullet Read 40 reviews 
 bullet Review this restaurant 

 

 

229 Darling St
Balmain NSW 2041

Phone (02) 9818 2170

 

view map Map   weather at Balmain Stars at GiGis' Weather  
tell friends Tell Friends   print review Print    Add to list Add to your list 

 

Look for

bullet Italian Restaurants in Sydney

 

What's nearby

bullet Restaurants & Cafes around Balmain

bullet Bars & Pubs around Balmain

 
 

 

Balmain Stars at GiGis' Details

229 Darling St
Balmain NSW 2041
Phone (02) 9818 2170

view map Map

Cuisine

Italian

Special Features

Has Cafe

 




Overall Rating              6.9  
 
Food                7.2  
Ambience                6.5  
Service                6.3  
Value                7.3  

 

Recommended based on 47 votes
(The Overall Rating is calculated using a Weighted Average)
       
 

 

 Been here? Rate Balmain Stars at GiGis', Balmain!
 

 

Please read our review guidelines and tips

 

 Awful Mediocre Perfect
  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10  
Food  
Ambience  
Service  
Value  
 
 Your Review *  
 
 

 

Already a member? Please login:

 

 Login Name  
 Password  
 Keep me logged in on this computer unless I logout   help
 (Non members may register on the next page)

 

 

 

 

User Reviews on Balmain Stars at GiGis'


 
Displaying 1 - 10 of 40 comments
 
Page: 1  2  3  4   Next
 

 

 

Overall             Average
Food 7 Ambience 6 Service 2 Value 4

 

The veal dishes are delicious but small in quantity, do not bother with the entrees as the main meals are a couple dollars more and better value. Also, do not take your wifes, or girlfriends to this place, the male staff (except for the friendly dark waiter) will be perving at your partners and exchange numbers with girls having their hens night parties. Sleazy service coupled with average food. A table of females would be best looked after.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
facereality  -   See my reviews 1review, 06 October 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Highly Recommended
Food 9 Ambience 9 Service 10 Value 9

 

Love this local restaurant. They are kid friendly and always do a special order for my picky child. A family favourite with us. The food never disappoints and the staff go out of their way to make you feel like one of the family. Service is always good considering the amount of people that come and go especially on a Friday and Saturday nights.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
gigi_balmain  -   See my reviews 3reviews, 23 September 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Highly Recommended
Food 9 Ambience 9 Service 9 Value 9

 

This palce is just fantastic. Went here for a birthday one year, and we had the rooftop terrace with fairy lights & thankfully, no rain. Despite being way out the back, about as far from the kitchen as possible, and there were 25 people in our group, the service was perfectly paced, ridiculously huge servings on the banquet meal, and the quality of food was unreal!

If people compain about the pizza being thin or bland, they obviously haven't travelled outside Australia, as we have pizza in this country, Stars at GiGis does the most amazing fresh pizza with incredible ingredients, and with cute names (aquarius, gemini, etc.).

I truly love this place, and it seems that the people that are bagging it out in other reviews are either too uptight, in a rush, or looking for "Australian" pizza, not the real deal. Definitely try it! The service is lovely, and although you won't rush-in-rush-out, that's not what you go here for!
 
Was this review helpful?
 
Haushinka  -   See my reviews 3reviews, 17 September 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 8 Ambience 6 Service 6 Value 8

 

I rate this restaurant above average to very good, its traditional Sicilian style pizza. One thing that is important is that it is still fully family run, the quality is consistent however their prices have gone up the upper end and there is no other comparison down Balmain. Unless you like that gourmet style pizza. They spend a lot of the afternoon preparing which you don't see that often anymore in Pizza estab.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
Gundapi  -   See my reviews 47reviews, 14 August 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 7 Ambience 7 Service 7 Value 9

 

Went here with 5 girlfirends. Shared pizza's and they were very tasty. It's BYO so that's great. Not expensive at all.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
yumtum  -   See my reviews 4reviews, 25 June 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 9 Ambience 7 Service 7 Value 7

 

Dined her with my parents in Jan 08. The food was great and the serves huge. It was value for money as it is not a cheap place to eat. Service was friendly and we had decent breaks between meals, didn't feel like they were trying to hurry us out.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
LLB  -   See my reviews 5reviews, 25 March 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Below Average
Food 5 Ambience 8 Service 2 Value 1

 

At first I was impressed by the ambience, however after leaving I was actually quite angry. An appalling wait for food - at least 45 minutes between each course. Food itself was okay but nothing to write home about. However, the portions of food after such long waits made my blood boil. Paid $40 for 2x Appletisers, 2 pieces of thin, boring pizza, a fifth of a plate of somewhat cold pasta, and a little bit of salad at the start as an entree.

What's more, though I wasn't tempted - it was quite clear that the only thing that the waiter and waitress were pushing was the serving of drinks. 10 minute wait to be asked if you wanted another drink, but at least a 45 minute wait to even get a glimpse of a tiny portioned, luke warm, and completely unsatisfying food.

Quite frankly, if I could have rated the value and service at zero, even then I would have felt as if that wasn't quite enough to portray the experience we had.
A terrible dining experience.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
timfletcher83  -   See my reviews 1review, 20 March 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Highly Recommended
Food 10 Ambience 10 Service 10 Value 10

 

I can't believe that Stars has such a mediocre rating. I have been coming here for years and the food, service and staff are fabulous. The staff are always accommodating, attentive and friendly - never ever had a bad experience there.
I really love the heart lollipops that you get at the counter! A cute touch.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
iloveagoodrestaurant  -   See my reviews 3reviews, 03 January 2008
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 

 

Overall             Recommended
Food 8 Ambience 8 Service 9 Value 8

 

Food is delicous, service is great and staff are friend and helpful.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
leens  -   See my reviews 1review, 08 July 2007
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 

 
  0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
 
 

 

Overall             Not Recommended
Food 1 Ambience 4 Service 2 Value 1

 

Food was average, no taste nothing. Service was shocked. Never back there.
 
Was this review helpful?
 
thomasdi  -   See my reviews 1review, 16 May 2007
bullet Manage this Listing to respond
 


Displaying 1 - 10 of 40 comments
Page: 1  2  3  4   Next


 
 

Featured Offers


special offer   Adriatic
Darlinghurst
 
special offer   Alio
East Redfern
 
special offer   Bistro Lilly
Sydney
 
special offer   Cala Luna
Mosman
 
special offer   Criniti's
Parramatta
 
special offer   Elevate
Parramatta
 
special offer   Giardinetto
Darlinghurst
 
special offer   Limani
Narrabeen
 
special offer   Raavi's Cumin
Crows Nest
 
special offer   Sam Satay
Surry Hills
 
special offer   Sanders Waterfront
Cabarita
 
special offer   Sea la vie
Dee Why Beach
 
special offer